A Guide to Montclair’s Best Coffee Shops

For those who have the willpower to pass on the convenience of Starbucks and Dunkin Donuts to #shopsmall, here is a guide to all of the locally-owned coffee shops in Montclair. We’ve rounded up the coffee options according to menu options, kinds of milk available, baked goods, and of course, ambiance so keep reading for the list of Montclair coffee shops.

Disclaimer: This list is growing, so if you know of one that we missed, email hello@themontclairgirl.com 

Bluestone Coffee | 123 Watchung Avenue

Bluestone Coffee

Photo credit: @bluestonecoffeeco

You didn’t hear it from us, but word on the street is you might catch Montclair native and celebrity Stephen Colbert stopping by for his AM brew at this local café. Bluestone Coffee is a unique addition to this list as an Australian-owned spot, roasting the beans in-house, which are also available for purchase. It’s rich and strong, which is perfect to fuel your morning. 

Non-dairy milk available: coconut, almond, and soy

Boho Cafe | 113 Watchung Avenue

Boca Life

Photo credit: Boho Cafe

The Boho Cafe is a sister business to the Boho Hair Salon, and was founded with a mission to connect people and create an inviting space. The shop brews organic Canyon Coffee, which is also available for purchase. Boho Cafe has a variety of syrup add-ins to customize your coffee experience. Some favorites include the coconut cream and the salted caramel, and there is always a house-made seasonal syrup to check out. 

Non-dairy milk available: almond and oat   

Coffee + Cornbread | 38 Upper Montclair Plaza

Coffee + Cornbread

Photo credit: @coffeeandcornbread

This vegan-friendly, Black-owned café offers delicious organic coffee and hot chocolate in addition to the enticing food menu. Coffee & Cornbread also has a rewards program and a subscription service offering exclusive deals and savings for customers. 

Non-dairy milk available: almond, rice, and oat

Read More: A Guide to the Best BYOB Restaurants in Montclair

Eagle Rock Co. | 202 Bellevue Avenue

Eagle Rock Co.

Photo credit: @eaglerockco

Eagle Rock is more than just a pretty face. This Insta-worthy shop brews Intelligentsia drip coffee and espresso drinks. The shop also hosts Sip + Learn events open to the community and are available for private events. 

Non-dairy milk available: almond and oat

Java Love | 244 Bellevue Avenue + 49 Church Street

Java Love

Photo credit: @doyoujavalove

Whether uptown or downtown in Montclair, there is a cozy corner to enjoy a cup of joe at Java Love. All the coffee is either organic and/or sustainably farmed, fair trade, or rainforest alliance-certified, which means the best of the best. Java Love also has great seasonal specialty drinks as well as both sweet and savory baked goods. On top of serving customers a daily dose of caffeine, Java Love also serves the surrounding community by hosting coffee classes, live music, game nights, and other events.

Non-dairy milk available: coconut, oat, almond, and soy

Local Coffee | 107 Watchung Avenue

Local Coffee

Photo credit: @localcoffeemontclair

Local Coffee is family-owned and operated, and is brewing hot beverages and bringing decadent pastries from some of the best vendors throughout New York and New Jersey. All of the coffee is sourced from Irving Farm Coffee Roasters, the tea is harvested from Tay Tea, and you can find an assortment of treats from Balthazar Bakery and Granola Lab. The mid-century aesthetic is goals.

Non-dairynmilk available: oat, almond, and soy

Mattarello Bakery + Cafe | 254 Bellevue Avenue

Mattarello Bakery

Mattarello’s offers dozens of baked goods and specialty coffees. Some delicious menu items include Nutella bites, ‘St. Joseph’s Cream Puffs’, and gluten-free chocolate Caprese. 

Non-dairy milk available: oat, almond, and soy

Paper Plane | 194 Claremont Avenue

Paper Plane

Photo credit: @paperplanecoffeeco

The coffee served at Paper Plane has origins over 150 years old, beginning on a family farm in the mountains of Colombia. The shop also offers all the classics but also provides a unique selection of pour-over coffees, coffee soda (think cherry-vanilla soda and espresso), and an entire section of the menu dedicated to science. Yes, science. The drinks found in this section experiment with temperatures and complementing flavors like chocolate, spices, and fruits. Paper Plane takes the traditional coffee break to a whole new level. 

Non-dairy milk options: oat, almond, and soy 

See More: All About The Tea Company Cafe in Montclair

Red Eye | 94 Walnut Street

red eye cafe

Photo credit: @redeyecafe

When there’s time to sit down or take a stroll, we recommend doing so with a cup of joe from Red Eye. Located in the heart of Walnut Street, this Montclair staple brews organic, fair trade, and rainforest-alliance certified Kobrick coffee and espresso. Try the signature ‘sludge’ made from cold-brewed espresso and cardamom or add organic CBD to any beverage.   

Non-dairy milk options: almond, oat, and soy

The Corner | 115 Grove Street

The Corner

Photo credit: @thecornermontclair

This popular brunch and rendezvous spot serves up all the best La Colombe blends, but don’t feel obliged to stay and eat. The coffee bar menu is simple and to the point, however, there is a little secret and it is the draft latte. There will not be any effects of alcohol however, this rich and creamy coffee is coming out of a tap… just give it a shot (pun intended) and it will shake up your routine. This spot also has the cutest Instagram-worthy decor, inside and out.

Non-dairy milk available: almond and soy

Vesta Chocolate | 598 Valley Road, Suite 2

  Vesta Chocolate

Come to revel in endless amounts of chocolate decadence and then stay for the extra caffeine boost from a delicious coffee. The couple behind Vesta Chocolate has served under some of the most prestigious restaurants and brands in the food world and feels strongly about bringing luxury to everyday treats, like chocolate and coffee. Albeit a simple menu, the coffee drinks are rich and work well to compliment all the bonbons, baked goods, and bars. 

Non-dairy milk option: oat

Want to stay in-the-know? Sign up for our weekly newsletter HERE.


Written by:

Gabriela grew up in Bergen County and moved to the Montclair area in 2016 in search of new experiences. She fell in love with the restaurant scene and stayed for the diversity, culture, and entrepreneurial spirit. Outside of her 9-5 as a Construction Operations Manager in Manhattan, you can find her enjoying meals at all her favorite restaurants, jamming out during Nine-Deeez-Nite at Just Jakes, or sitting outside Amanti Vino sipping wine with friends.


Appears within: