Home Best of Guides Where to Order Thanksgiving Pies in Montclair + Beyond

Where to Order Thanksgiving Pies in Montclair + Beyond

by Erica Commisso
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail

November is finally here — which means Thanksgiving is on its way, and it’s great to start planning early. Thanksgiving is full of traditions — some are family-related, some are sports-related. But an argument could be made that the most important traditions are the food traditions, because let’s face it, food is such an important part of this holiday. There is nothing better than a Thanksgiving pie, made fresh and sweet. Several Essex County businesses serve up sweet treats — the perfect pinnacle of pie for a Thanksgiving dinner. We’ve rounded up where to find Thanksgiving pies in Montclair and the greater Essex County area in New Jersey. Read on to learn where to get Thanksgiving pies this holiday season in and around Montclair, NJ.

Disclaimer: This is a growing list. To request to be added, please send a note to [email protected].

thanksgiving pies montclair essex county

The Ivy at Chatham

The Able Baker | 187 Maplewood Avenue, Maplewood


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by The Able Baker (@theablebaker)


Order deadlines for Thanksgiving pies at this small business are November 15th, and there are a variety of options for every sweet tooth. Pumpkin, pecan, and salted maple pies are all available, but the most popular option is the local apple double-crust pie. You can pick up the pies on November 21st or November 22nd; click here to order.

Read More: Where to Find Fall-Themed Spirits + Drinks in Northern New Jersey

In the Company of Yum | Based Out of Montclair


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by In the Company of Yum (@companyofyum)

This online pie company is a woman- and minority-owned business selling stunning pies in a variety of flavors. Owner Jessica Glass works hard to ensure everyone can celebrate all occasions with pie. The Thanksgiving menu recently went live and features options like apple, sweet potato, apple butter pumpkin, pecan, and even a mini pie sampler if you’re having trouble deciding.

Jayce Baudry French Pastry | 17 Church Street, Montclair


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Jayce Baudry French Pastry (@jaycebaudryfrenchpastry)


This French bakery is taking pre-orders online starting now. Pick-up options begin as early as November 14th and run through the 23rd. The Thanksgiving menu can be found here — and it features stunning (we mean it, stunning) pies like apple cinnamon crumb pie, pumpkin spice pie, and chocolate bourbon pecan pie. 

Ladyfingers Bakery + Bar | 1109 Broad Street, Bloomfield


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Ladyfingers Bakery + Bar (@ladyfingersbakeryandbar)


This newly opened bakery is currently accepting orders for Thanksgiving pies until November 16th. Customers can email orders to [email protected] or call and ask for a manager at 973-323-1680. Pies available include chocolate pudding pie, dutch apple pie, and pumpkin pie — all priced at $29.95. Pecan Pie is also available for $32.95.

Libelula Bakery and Kitchen5 N Fullerton Avenue, Montclair

This spot brings Peruvian, Dominican, and Latino culinary culture to the Montclair food scene. This Thanksgiving, it will be providing Thanksgiving pies and even catering to order for the holiday. Pie choices include Spiced Apple Pie, Pumpkin Tart,  Chocolate Salted Caramel, and Pecan Pie Bars (sold in a dozen or half-dozen). Call the bakery + restaurant via the phone number (973)-707-2082 for more information. 

Mattarello Bakery + Café | 254 Bellevue Avenue, Montclair


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Mattarello Bakery & Café (@mattarellobakery)

With doughnuts, cakes, gluten-free items, and more, this local Montclair bakery is also a great place to buy pies for the holidays. From apple pie to Nutella pie to apricot, there are lots of yummy choices here. Readers can find the menu for online ordering here.

Palmer’s Bakehouse | 1 Highland Place, Maplewood


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Palmer’s Bakehouse (@palmersbakehouse)


At Palmer’s Bakehouse, pre-orders for pies are now being accepted until November 19th. This includes the salted caramel pie, pecan pie, pumpkin cream pie, sweet potato cheesecake pie, and more. There are also biscuits, scones, and many other sweet offerings as well.



The Little Daisy Bake Shop | 622 Valley Road, Montclair


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by The Little Daisy Bake Shop (@littledaisybakeshop)


Known for its colorful baked goods such as cookies, cakes, scones, and whoopie pies, this Montclair shop has curated its own Thanksgiving menu. Pie choices include pumpkin pie, key lime pie, and apple crumb pie. There are also other sweets like pumpkin spice cake or cheesecake. Click here to schedule a pick time and browse the entire Thanksgiving selection.

The Pie Store | 100 Watchung Avenue, Montclair


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by The Pie Store (@thepiestore)


This bakery’s specialty is sweet and savory British pies, alongside groceries imported from the UK. The shop offers in-store and online delivery, and the sweet pies, like apple, and cran-apple, complement savory pies and hearty soups for a one-stop Thanksgiving shop.

Plum Bakery Gluten-Free | 179 Glenridge Avenue, Montclair


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Plum Bakery 100% Gluten-Free (@plumbakerygf)


Gluten-free eaters: this one is for you. Plum Bakery is accepting orders until November 18th at 4PM. The Thanksgiving online orders can be picked up on November 22nd after 11AM. You can find options like apple crumb, cranberry apple crumb, coconut custard, pumpkin, and more.  Click here to order.

See More: Your Guide to Thanksgiving Pies in Hoboken, Jersey City, + Bayonne

Stuff by SJ | 342 Bloomfield Avenue, Montclair


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Stuff by SJ (@stuffbysj)


This woman-owned small business makes handmade cakes, cupcakes, treats, and — of course — pies. These beautiful Thanksgiving pies can be picked up ahead of time, or you can sign up for free local delivery on November 22nd. On the menu is a pumpkin pecan streusel, a classic apple pie, a Dutch apple pie, and a classic pumpkin pie. You can pre-order your Thanksgiving pie here.

read more button

also appears in

0 comment