Home Best of Guides A List of Must-Try Pasta Spots in the Montclair Area

A List of Must-Try Pasta Spots in the Montclair Area

by Samantha Impaglia
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail

Pasta is a staple of Italian cuisine, and here in New Jersey, there are so many amazing dishes one can find, from the classic to the creative. Essex County has such a wide range of restaurants to choose from, so it might be hard to find just the right place. We’ve compiled a list of all the best pasta spots in Essex County and their standout dishes. Read on to see our picks and why we love them.

Arturo’s | 180 Maplewood Avenue, Maplewood

arturos maplewood

(Photo credit: @arturos.nj)

Arturo’s of Maplewood is a  classic Italian restaurant with its casual, comfortable dining room. In addition to being known for pizza, the menu includes an incredible pasta selection. There are simpler dishes like the highly-recommended Mushroom Ravioli with truffle oil garlic rosemary sauce, along with more eclectic ones. The Cinghiale is made with wild boar ragu Bianco and mushrooms, and the Cavatelli Siciliani includes chiles, capers, anchovies, and pine nuts.

Special Diets
Vegan: yes
Vegetarian: yes
Gluten-free: yes

Bucco | 61 Washington Street, Bloomfield

bucco bloomfield

(Photo credit: @buccorestaurantbloomfield)

Bucco is a simple Italian establishment with rustic vibes. It has a robust pasta menu that will leave anyone satisfied, including a Sunday special of “Grandma’s Sunday Gravy” served over rotini. The Stuffed Rigatoni Pasta is a favorite among customers, along with the Spaghetti White Clam Sauce. Other dishes that stand out include Braised Beef Short Rib Ravioli, and Spaghetti Bucco with asparagus, sun-dried tomatoes, long hot peppers, garlic and oil, parmesan, and provolone cheese.

Special Diets
Vegan: yes
Vegetarian: yes
Gluten-free: yes

Cafe Giotto | 42 Church Street, Montclair

Cafe Giotto montclair

(Photo credit: @cafegiottomontclair)

Cafe Giotto’s pasta is house-made along with the rest of their specialty Italian products. The chic design makes it a picture-perfect spot, going along with the upscale menu. Cavatelli, gnocchi, spaghetti, and tagliatelle can be enjoyed four ways – with pomodoro, pesto, agile e olio, or bolognese – and there are several specialty pastas. Along with daily specials like cavatelli with crumbled sweet sausage and roasted red peppers, and the top-rated Truffle Tortelloni, the specialties include Fazzoletti with spinach, ricotta, butter, and sage, and seasonal ravioli and risotto.

Special Diets
Vegan: yes
Vegetarian: yes
Gluten-free: yes

Read More: These Restaurants + Bars in Montclair Will Wow Your Visitors

da Pepo | 54 Fairfield Street, Montclair

da pepo montclair

(Photo credit: @dapepomontclair)

Da Pepo, The Montclair Girl’s winner for the best pasta in the “Best of Montclair 2021,” has a warm atmosphere that’s perfect to enjoy this food. The traditional Italian recipes, made in-house, are learned from Italian ancestors, making the pasta selection top-notch. The Penne Arrabiata catches the eye with red onion, olives, hot cherry peppers, San Marzano tomato, and cream, as well as the Spaghetti Carbonara with guanciale, egg, pecorino romano, and black pepper.

Special Diets
Vegan: yes
Vegetarian: yes
Gluten-free: yes

Fascino | 331 Bloomfield Avenue, Montclair

fascino montclair

(Photo credit: @fascino_restaurant)

Fascino offers upscale Italian pasta with more of an intimate setting. Modern and seasonal dishes are made in-house, and included on the “Italian Without Borders” menu that is known as one of the best in the area. The Ricotta Gnocchi is a customer favorite, and the most unique pasta is the Squid Ink Pappardelle with shrimp and crab ragu, chili oil, and brown butter-citrus crumbs. Fascino also has spaghetti, rigatoni, and Okinawa sweet potato and taleggio agnolotti dishes.

Special Diets
Vegan: yes
Vegetarian: yes
Gluten-free: yes

Laboratorio Kitchen | 615 Bloomfield Avenue, Montclair

Laboratorio kitchen montclair

(Photo credit: @laboratoriokitchen)

Healthy, locally sourced ingredients are the focus of Laboratorio Kitchen’s dishes. As an upscale dining experience, the pasta is more gourmet than others. Along with the popular house-made ravioli appetizer, the Hand-Rolled Ricotta Cavatelli and Fresh Rigatoni Pasta with Italian sausage, broccoli rabe, fresh garlic, and tomato cream sauce offer fresh meals that make you feel good.

Special Diets
Vegan: yes
Vegetarian: yes
Gluten-free: yes

La Rocca Osteria | 21 Midland Avenue, Montclair

la rocca osteria montclair

(Photo credit: @larocca.osteria)

As a chic and simple Italian spot, La Rocca Osteria offers many pasta dishes as well as specials. The Tagliolini Seafood Pasta with lobster, crabmeat, and shrimp in a light cherry tomato sauce is a hearty, popular plate, and a house-made lasagna sits next to it on the specials. More of the robust options include Linguine Vongole with manila clams, garlic, and parsley, Tagliatelle Bolognese, and gnocchi with La Rocca tomato sauce and smoked provolone.

Special Diets
Vegan: no
Vegetarian: yes
Gluten-free: yes

Mama Dag’s Seafood and Pizza House | 410 Saint Cloud Avenue, West Orange

mama dags west orange

(Photo credit: @mamadags_seafood)

On its extensive menu, Mama Dag’s Seafood and Pizza House includes a bunch of classic Italian pasta good for any occasion. It is another place that makes its own pasta, and the simple dining room is full of dark blue walls. In addition to Pappardelle Bolognese, a favorite amongst customers, Mama Dag’s has a signature pasta dish of Spaghetti Polpette, which is An Italian-American classic of “Sunday gravy” according to the restaurant’s website. There’s classic Penne Vodka, Orecchiette Broccoli Rabe, and two vegetarian options  – Fettuccine Carbonara, and Cavatelli Cauliflower – for anyone who wants it.

Special Diets
Vegan: no
Vegetarian: yes
Gluten-free: yes

Matthew’s Italian Restaurant | 1131 Bloomfield Avenue, Clifton

Matthews Italian restaurant Clifton

(Photo credit: @matthewsitalianrestaurant)

Matthew’s Italian Restaurant is about as classic Italian as it gets. It is a clean, sophisticated space that has become quite popular in its 12-year existence. The Rigatoni Vodka there never fails with its many rave reviews, and the rest of the pasta selection focuses on simple but effective dishes. What really intrigues customers is the “Sunday Sauce” that’s only available on that day; including slow-simmered country-style ribs, braciole, spicy sausage, and meatballs served over fresh rigatoni with a side of ricotta and basil. 

Special Diets
Vegan: yes
Vegetarian: yes
Gluten-free: yes

Nicolas Anthony’s Family Kitchen | 450 Main Street, West Orange

Manicotti and Penne Vodka are staples on the menu at this straightforward Italian restaurant. For a vegetarian option, the Penne Sicilia with fresh mozzarella, grape tomato, and basil is offered without chicken or shrimp, and for a bit of a kick, there’s the Tuscan Rigatoni with sausage, broccoli rabe, cherry peppers, and white beans garlic and oil. The most unique pasta dish is the Penne Nicolas Anthony, consisting of crab, shrimp, asparagus, grape tomato, and champagne cream sauce.

Special Diets
Vegan: no
Vegetarian: yes
Gluten-free: yes

Palato | 377 Bloomfield Avenue, Montclair

palato montclair

(Photo Credit: @palatos_caffe_cucina)

Palato aims to be fresh, organic, and authentic. The interior’s industrial vibes scattered with chic decor make it a great place to enjoy some pasta. The Fettuccine ai Funghi is served with mixed mushrooms in garlic and truffle oil, while the Trofie al Nero di Seppia consists of squid ink pasta with crab meat, garlic, and Fresno pepper for a unique twist.

Special Diets
Vegan: yes
Vegetarian: yes
Gluten-free: yes

Pappardelle Ristorante | 77 Walnut Street, Montclair

pappardelle montclair

(Photo credit: @pappardeller)

There are so many pasta dishes to choose from at Pappardelle Ristorante, which can be easily identified by its red awning out front. There are four different plates of Pappardelle prepared in different ways, including the Chicken Tarantella with sautéed chicken, portobello mushrooms, prosciutto, and roasted peppers in a verde pesto sauce. From Capellini Shrimp and Arugula to Fettuccine al Salmone, to Lobster Ravioli, and more, Pappardelle has everyone covered when it comes to eating pasta.

Special Diets
Vegan: no
Vegetarian: yes
Gluten-free: yes

Popolari | 1047 Broad Street, Bloomfield

popolari bloomfield

(Photo Credit: @lapopolari)

Popolari is a bit different from the traditional Italian places, offering an upbeat, retro pizzeria vibe. The Spicy Vodka Pasta comes highly recommended as a classic dish with a twist, along with the Popolari Gnocchi in a pistachio basil pesto creme sauce. Another one of the signature dishes is the Malfaldine e Fungi Truffel, served with homemade ribbon pasta, and sautéed mixed mushrooms in a porcini creme sauce. For someone that wants to enjoy one of these plates but is gluten-free, any of the pasta dishes can be made to accommodate.

Special Diets
Vegan: yes
Vegetarian: yes
Gluten-free: yes

Primavera | 500 Pleasant Valley Way, West Orange

primavera west orange

(Photo credit: @primaverawestorange)

Primavera of West Orange has a ton of pasta options as well. The large, open dining room gives off warm vibes in a comfortable area. Traditional dishes like Gnocchi Bolognese and Penne Rigate con Vodka are on the menu, as well as Lobster Ravioli, Whole Wheat Linguini Primavera, and Four Cheese Ravioli. The Cavatelli Nona offers something that is not on every menu, consisting of homemade cavatelli, creamy ricotta cheese tomato basil sauce, diced eggplant, and melted fontina cheese.

Special Diets
Vegan: no
Vegetarian: yes
Gluten-free: yes

See More: Bloom in Verona: French-Korean Cuisine Created by a Local Chef

Salute Brick Oven Bistro | 173 Glenridge Avenue, Montclair

salute bistro montclair

(Photo credit: @salutebistro)

With a goalto bring customers an Italian hill town dining experience, Salute Brick Oven Bistro stands by being an authentic Italian eatery. In the casual setting, diners can enjoy the popular Ravioli with Braised Short Rib, and Truffled Shiitake and Porcini Mushrooms, or a classic Potato Gnocchi in cherry tomato sughetto. The Spaghettini is sure to fill anyone up with littleneck clams, crispy pancetta, white wine, and chili flakes. All of the homemade pasta can be prepared gluten-free or whole wheat. 

Special Diets
Vegan: yes
Vegetarian: yes
Gluten-free: yes

Scala Del Nonna | 32 Church Street, Montclair

scala del nonna montclair

(Photo Credit: @scaladelnonna)

Scala Del Nonna’s bright, chic vibe makes the space so inviting. The Ricotta Gnocchi con Salsiccia e Porcini is one of the favorites here, and there is endless robust Italian pasta to choose from besides that. Coming from the chef’s Italian cooking background, the dishes here are perfect in their simplicity. Some of the options include Linguini al Carbonara, Lasagnette con Vodka, and Spaghetti al Bolognese.

Special Diets
Vegan: no
Vegetarian: yes
Gluten-free: yes

Turtle + the Wolf | 622 Valley Road, Upper Montclair

turtle + the wolf upper montclair

(Photo Credit: @turtleandthewolf)

Although there are only two pasta dishes here, they are worth a try. Turtle + the Wolf is an industrial-chic eatery with strong roots in Montclair, as the owner actually grew up in town. The two kinds of pasta offered include a Hand-Cut Pappardelle and Pork Sumo with roasted pork shoulder, as well as a Three-Cheese Agnolotti with marinated spring vegetables and strawberries.

Special Diets
Vegan: yes
Vegetarian: yes
Gluten-free: yes

also appears in

0 comment