New Jersey is well known for its beaches and the Jersey Shore — but what many may not know is that New Jersey also has a rich mermaid history. Whether or not you believe in these sea creatures, tales of New Jersey mermaids span back centuries. Read on to learn more about the history and legends of mermaid folklore in New Jersey.
In 1609, before he came upon the river we now call by his name, English explorer Henry Hudson documented his crew’s sighting of a mermaid off the coast of Greenland:
“By that time shee was come close to the ship’s side, looking earnestly on the men a little after, a sea came and overturned her from the navill upward, her backe and breasts were, like a woman’s, as they say that saw her. Her body as big as one of us, her skin very white and long haire hanging downe behinde, of colour blacke. In her going down they saw her tayle, which was like the tayle of a porposse, and speckled like a macrell.”
(Photo credit: Public Domain)
19th-century illustration of Henry Hudson’s ship, the Halve Maen
Hudson’s matter-of-fact account suggests the explorer didn’t question the reality of mermaids. They were rare, but not so unusual. Sadly, Hudson didn’t see any merpeople in the area surrounding what is now New York and New Jersey. But others of his era did see water women along our coasts.
River Woman of the Shatemuc
A traditional Lenni Lenape story tells of a boy taken by a sudden rushing wave while he was walking through a stream that was normally calm and safe to cross. The boy’s friends, who’d witnessed the awful event, described to his parents his sudden disappearance under the water.
The parents of the boy went to a seer who told them that their son was alive and had been taken by a water woman. They were told that they could find their son if, at sunrise, they camped on the bank of the great river fed by the stream where their son had disappeared. The Lenape called what we refer to as the Hudson River, ‘the Shatemuc,’ and it is there that the people awaited the water woman.
Much to their surprise, the boy appeared — and he wasn’t alone. The Lenape story goes, “Before the hour, a great crowd gathered at the appointed place, and the mysterious deep began to roll and throw forth great whirlpools. And thunder or rumbling sounds burst into the air. At sunrise, behold, they saw on the waves of the great river the missing boy. At his side was a beautiful humanlike personage, said to be a mermaid.”
By the nineteenth century, mermaids were an international sensation. In 1842, the circus showman, P.T. Barnum exhibited a gruesome construction that he called the “Fejee Mermaid.” This less than beautiful spectacle was actually an assemblage of at least two animal corpses — hardly the stuff that dreams are made of. Still, it drew crowds to New York from all around.
(Photo credit: Public Domain)
Barnum exhibited the Fejee Mermaid in New York with great success for about a month. A Dr. Griffin, Barnum’s partner in the mermaid scheme and a fraudster posing as a naturalist, gave lectures explaining to the crowds flooding the New York Concert Hall that all land-dwelling animals have counterparts in the ocean (e.g.: sea horses, sea lions… ). It obviously followed that sea-people would exist as well.
Tom’s River Mermaid
In 1869, an actual New Jersey mermaid was widely reported to have been found off the coast of Tom’s River. News accounts express disappointment that the fishermen who caught her were so frightened as to throw her back into the sea from which she’d come. But there would probably have been a curse in keeping her, so it’s likely better that they let her go.
A full century later, Olson’s Bar and Grill on Tom River’s Route 37 featured a mermaid posed as ‘food’ on its iconic restaurant roof. Today, that sign is no longer, but a Mermaid Road does exist and locals occasionally report sights of iridescent tail fins flashing in the waves at twilight.
A Novel Concept
One would think that authors aplenty would have documented tales of mermaids roaming our waters. But only a few published accounts exist that record this maritime history. New York Times bestselling artist and author Mark Siegel’s graphic novel, Sailor Twain: Or the Mermaid in the Hudson, tells a lusty love story that takes place on a Hudson River steamship during the Gilded Age.
Well-loved author Alice Hoffman’s The Museum of Extraordinary Things starts where Barnum’s Fejee Mermaid exploit ended. Her 2014 historical fiction novel centers on a girl who becomes entangled with mer-adventure on the cliffs of the Palisades. Then, there is the tale that real estate agent and storyteller Christina Sciarretta has spun for the sake of her children. Hers is an internet yarn of a mermaid named Waverly who collects treasure at the New Jersey Shore. Perhaps future writers will also see fit to give witness to the merfolk who live here.
The gorgeously illustrated Sailor Twain features a wounded mermaid whose caregiver becomes supernaturally obsessed with her, in the vein of old siren song stories. The health and medical treatment of mermaids is often on the mind of Sara Weller, a Jersey City resident who works to program tours of the abandoned hospitals on Ellis Island. She notes that just as lighthouse keepers were provided medical care in those once state-of-the-art medical facilities, so too could have the mermaids injured by steamships, ferries, and fishermen.
See More: What’s Going on at Lackawanna Plaza
Mer-Events Coming Soon
To be and see a mermaid, one need go no further than the Coney Island Mermaid Parade. This year, fin-tastic costumes will be donned on Saturday, June 18th, for the 40th annual parade. New Jersey’s Asbury Park has hosted its own Promenade of Mermaids and will, if we are lucky, do so again in the future.
To see real-life mermaids as they swim beneath the waves, the Camden Adventure Aquarium is the place to go. Mermaids swim among 15,000 more typical but no less magical sea creatures within the aquarium’s shark tank in this annual event. When back on land, the Camden Adventure Aquarium mermaids provide environmental lessons to their visitors.
Water’s Soul in Jersey City
The Newport area of Jersey City adds a mermaid sighting that is the easiest to glimpse. Water’s Soul (aka The Shushing Woman) may exist in plain sight, but we see only the very top of her. Sculptor Juame Plensa describes her as an elusive water spirit. He has placed her massive white head upon a pier on the Hudson waterfront, but what lies beneath? Quite possibly, a tail. Is that the secret we are meant to keep?